A stand-up cop

July 31, 2014 § 40 Comments

When Laura Weintraub posted her inane video, insinuating that hitting cyclists in your car was not only good, but something that everyone secretly wants to do, the shit hit the Internet. She is now in hiding, having received death threats and having been told that she would be decapitated. She has also been booted off the Santa Paula police force, where she served for three years in the records department as a reserve officer.

She will never work in law enforcement again.

Moral of the story: The Internet’s a bitch, yo.

But as with every story, there’s a back story as well. When Chief Steve McLean offered to talk with anyone who had concerns about Ms. Weintraub’s “embarrassing” video, I took him up on the offer. Expecting voicemail, I was surprised to speak with the chief himself. “You pick the day and time, and I’ll clear my calendar for you,” he said.

So last Friday, Eric Bruins of LA County Bicycle Coalition, Nina Moskol of the Santa Clarita Valley Bicycle Coalition, Randi Zabriskie of Yield to Life, her husband David, and I met with Chief McLean in Santa Paula to figure out what had happened and how we could make some lemonade. Quickly.

What became clear after only a few minutes is the following:

  1. Chief McLean took responsibility for his employee, even though Ms. Weintraub made it off the clock, as a civilian, in a different city, in a different county, and never affiliated herself or the video with the police department.
  2. Administrative action was immediately taken against Ms. Weintraub. She was put on leave, then terminated from the force. This all happened in less than 72 hours.
  3. Despite the fact that none of Ms. Weintraub’s actions had any affiliation with the department, the city and the police department felt the full wrath of the bicycling community.

Many people might be fine with that last part. I’m not, because it turns out that Santa Paula is hardly the bike-hating, cyclist-murdering place that Ms. Weintraub’s actions have wrongly made it out to be. The city has hosted the Amgen Tour of California three times. The city has implemented a $4.2 million bike trail, part of a rails-to-trails project that will ultimately connect Piru to Fillmore to Santa Paula to Ventura to the sea. Santa Paula is the first city in the project to complete its segment of the trail.

Santa Paula has recently completed the design phase for a Class II bike lane from Harvard Boulevard to Santa Paula Street. This $650,000, grant-funded project soon moves into the implementation phase. Additional planned projects will connect the bike lane to the rails-to-trails corridor.

The city is more than committed to the recreational and transportation side of cycling. It has three full-time bike officers, an impressive number for a city that only has 28 police officers total. An annual bike fair and bike rodeo have taken place in the city for years, and, what’s a revealing statistic for cyclists accustomed to getting harassed by law enforcement, there hasn’t been a single traffic citation written for a cyclist in the past year.

Tack on the fact that Santa Paula is a key part of the popular cycling corridor that goes to Ojai and Lake Casitas, and it’s no exaggeration to say that with regard to Ms. Weintraub’s actions, the city and its police department have gotten a bum rap. Unlike Calabasas, the city where Ms. Weintraub lives and shot the video, a city that is one of the wealthiest enclaves in California and the home to numerous celebrities and movie stars, Santa Paula is a gritty small town with significant social problems.

The biggest one is crime. The city has suffered from a plague of violent crime — nine murders last year alone — after the city council reduced the size of the police force. As LA-area gangs and drug runners have moved in, the city hired Chief McLean to deal with the problem. He reduced violent crime by 40% in his first year alone, this in a city where many of the families have one parent in jail, and where many others are headed by a single parent or by two parents who both work full time. With a shoestring budget, the police department and the community have done much in terms of outreach to bicycle riders.

Nonetheless, every city can improve when it comes to bike-car-community relations. Chief McLean took the meeting by the horns and worked with us to develop the following three proposals:

  1. Bring in a bicycle education course from LA County Bicycle Coalition, to be delivered to the city’s bicycle cops.
  2. Use the bicycle officers to perform outreach and education to the broader community at the annual bike expo and other venues.
  3. Designate two school resource officers to teach bicycle safety at the elementary and middle school level in Santa Paula.

We also discussed a wide-ranging series of possibilities for furthering bike-community-motorist awareness, not limited to an education and registration program modeled after the LA Sheriff’s Department program that Chief McLean spearheaded when he was captain at the Alta Dena Substation. What was clear was that increased coordination and cooperation with Santa Clarita Valley BC, LA County BC, and Yield to Life were all things that the department was more than willing to commit to.

What was also clear is that Chief McLean and his department deserve praise for the way they handled an incredibly tough situation. They’re ready to move ahead. Let’s judge them not by the mistakes made by a rogue employee, but by their efforts to make Santa Paula a better place to ride … and to live.



If this is the kind of advocacy you support, please subscribe to this blog: $2.99/month, cheap.

If you like Chief McLean’s attitude and approach, drop him a line on Facebook, Santa Paula Police Department, to voice your support.

Tagged: , , , , , , , , ,

§ 40 Responses to A stand-up cop

  • Barbara Radnofsky says:

    Seth, mediation is your calling. Most of the private, international mediators I know began as lawyers of all kinds. You might end up traveling to the Mid East or places in Africa or Ukraine or New Jersey, but surely it cannot be physically riskier than cycling.

  • Joe C says:

    Laura Weintraub’s video was horrible, but I’m also not too proud to be associated with the people who responded to it with threats of death and decapitation.

    Kudos to you, your group and the Chief for making lemonade though.

    • Darwin says:

      I call BS on the death threats.
      I seriously doubt she is “in hiding” as well.

    • fsethd says:

      Thanks. It’s good to know that there are people who not only take responsibility, but who use bad events as an opportunity for improvement.

  • Chris says:

    I say a big group ride to Santa Paula, complete with patronizing the local businesses is in order as a “Thank you”.

  • Rev says:

    Thanks for doing this Seth and lacbc. I suspect the reason that the police dept took a lot of heat is the fact that another employee defended the video on the dept’s Facebook page as satire, and said that cyclists are oblivious to the law. Many people (reasonably) thought it was an official statement and it just took off from there as internet trials do. But McLean is stand up from my limited dealings with him.

    • fsethd says:

      Yes, and she was a department employee. The chief took responsibility and the perpetrator was terminated.

      • Rev says:

        Well, technically he allowed her to resign, unless the situation changed. Eitehr way, positive news

  • Serge Issakov says:

    Thank you.

  • Peter says:

    I like Chris’s idea, count me in if you do a Santa Paula ride.

  • Rodley says:

    Thanks Seth for supporting us with all of your efforts.

  • Gary Cziko says:

    Lemonade indeed. Thanks for squeezing just right and adding the sugar.

  • Doug Johnstone says:

    Good grief. All this Dudley Do-good pro-active stuff is making me wonder if you’re not actually Canadian or something!!

    Good Job.

    BTW, I’m in for ride as well.

  • billdsd says:

    Nice proposals. Can’t have too much education.

  • Deborah says:

    I shared the original video, hopeful that some good would come of that irresponsible behavior. I think what you all have done here is just what needed to be done. Thanks for that.

  • Deborah says:

    Way to go to the group! What was a disastrous, irresponsible act has morphed into actions that other communities nationwide could use to promote cycling safety. Thanks for your efforts!

  • Waldo says:

    Chief McLean is awesome. Methinks he is not long for Santa Paula PD but is on his way to heading a much bigger department.

  • No one of consequence says:

    Way to add context to a story that had been polarized by viral media. Sounds like they have a good chief out there. Nice open back roads out that way and awesome fresh produce stands…it’s avocado season let’s all make some guac!

  • Dogg says:

    Should we mention that the world famous FTR rolls through Santa Paula on a yearly basis?!
    Dogg’s in-laws live there as well.

    Peace n Love to Santa Paula

  • supercoolchuy@yahoo.com says:

    I can not give the Chief enough praise. He is a true leader of a great department. Way to go Chief McLean and way to go Santa Paula PD! I’m excited to cycle through Santa Paula at their next event.

  • Matt McPhail says:

    I bet Ms.Weintraub is a Republican and listens to Rush Limbaugh.

    • fsethd says:

      Whatever her political affiliations, she advocates killing people simply because they ride bicycles.

  • 2ful1cap says:

    I’m a cyclist from Rome, Italy, yet I followed the Laura Weintraub case. Actually what Weintraub said and posted is a cliché common to many car-driver.

    I jumped onto this blog from the Drunkcyclist post (I think…) and I was not disappointed with the point of the post “An eye for an eye”. Now I see that Chief McLean is doing great job.

    Very very nice, we could use some “cop-bike-awareness” here in Italy…

  • Matt McPhail says:

    Sorry,sometimes my typing goes faster than my brain filter. Bad taste and out of line. Won’t happen again!

    • fsethd says:

      We like bad taste! And if you’re not out of line, you’re definitely on the wrong blog.

  • […] the bike-friendly department she barely worked for got an undeserved black eye based on the comments of someone who should have […]

  • jamnkats says:

    i live in Mexico and we have nothing but respect from the autos here but still have been reading along of this story and what a great update. thanks for reporting it

What’s this?

You are currently reading A stand-up cop at Cycling in the South Bay.


%d bloggers like this: